A sample from

Bring Nothing

Nobody on Atwells had ever looked twice at Libby Hartmann, and she had always found that useful.

By four o'clock on Ash Wednesday the light on Atwells had gone the color of weak tea, and Carlo had come back from the noon Mass at the bottom of the hill with a gray thumbprint on his forehead and had not looked in a mirror since. Libby had not told him. She had decided, around two, that a man who billed what Carlo billed could be trusted to know what day it was.

She had been at the front desk for four months. It was a two-room office three doors down from the pharmacy with the blue awning: her room at the front, with the window on the street and the gold letters on the glass that said CARLO M. FALCONE, ATTORNEY AT LAW backwards to her all day, and his room behind it, with the good rug and the door he left open unless somebody was crying. Between the two doors stood the file cabinet, four drawers of gray steel that had come with the lease and stuck at the third drawer unless you lifted while you pulled. She had learned the lift in her first week. She had learned his calendar in her second, his handwriting in her third, and by the end of the first month she had learned that Carlo's practice was Carlo's own, and not, whatever the people who came up the stairs seemed to assume, one of the family's businesses. He said so to anybody who asked. People on the hill did not seem to find it a meaningful distinction, and she had stopped expecting them to.

The Varga file lived in the third drawer, at the back, in two red expanding folders held with a rubber band she replaced whenever it went soft. Carlo had taken it out at lunch to read the other side's motion again and left it fanned across his blotter, which he did with everything, and which she put right every afternoon the way her mother put right a bed after the evening aide. She stood at his desk now and squared it.

The denial letter went on top, because it was the reason for the rest. It was two pages on the mutual's letterhead, the old-fashioned kind with the address over the bank set in small capitals, dated Thursday, 4 February, and signed at the bottom in a careful, upright hand: Arturo Falcone. Under it went the state fire marshal's cause-and-origin report, forty-one pages with photographs, which Carlo had subpoenaed and which had been served on the marshal's office by a G. Russo, whose affidavit of service was stapled to the front of it with his signature running off the line. Under that went the statement of the second-floor tenant, in a sealed inner envelope that she did not open and was not supposed to, with Carlo's initials across the flap.

It was not a complicated case, which was the thing about it she found hardest to put down at night. Kenneth Varga's three-decker in East Providence had burned at three in the morning in January of last year, the marshal had found the fire set on the back stairs, the mutual had refused to pay the claim after a year of looking at it, and Varga was suing for the money; Carlo was defending the refusal, and had asked the court to keep the name of the man who had seen somebody on those stairs out of Varga's hands, and Varga's lawyer had asked the court to make him hand it over. That was all of it. She had written the hearing date in Carlo's calendar in red and then gone over it again, which she did not do with anything else.

She put the folders back into their drawer, lifted, pushed, and heard the catch go home.

"You can leave at half past five," Carlo called from the front room, where he was standing at her window eating one of the almond cookies that the pharmacy owner's son-in-law brought up every Wednesday. "I mean that. Go home. Eat something that isn't from a vending machine."

"You've got three people at six."

"I can open a door."

"You can," Libby said. "You don't. You stand behind it and say come in, and then nobody knows whether to push."

He laughed, which was the best thing about him: he laughed as if being caught out were a gift somebody had brought him. He was a short, comfortable man in a navy three-piece, the waistcoat buttoned smooth over his middle, rimless glasses, and dark hair that he combed with a little oil in the morning and that by four in the afternoon had given up any pretense of staying where he had put it. The ash sat just under the wave, a smeared gray cross nobody had told him about.

"Your class is cancelled tonight," he said. "I checked. I know your schedule better than you think."

"You know it because I wrote it in your calendar."

"That's how I know everything."

She did not go home at half past five. She had not really expected to, and she suspected he had not expected her to either; he had only wanted to have said it. She put on the desk lamp instead, the green-shaded one that threw a hard circle across her blotter and left the corners of the room in brown, and she typed up two letters about a closing that had moved, and she wrote tomorrow's appointments into the green steno pad that sat by her right hand. The pad was the twentieth of its kind, or the thirtieth; she had stopped counting somewhere in college. She had been writing down instructions in green steno pads since she was twelve, beginning with her mother's shift schedule taped inside the kitchen cupboard, because a child who is running a house finds out very quickly that the thing nobody wrote down is the thing that goes wrong. She was twenty-four now. The habit had outlived the reason by a long time and she did not intend to give it up.

Outside, the street lamps came on along Atwells all at once, the way they did, and the window turned from a view into a mirror with a view behind it. She could see herself in it over the gold lettering: a pale-blue shirt, the collar open, small pearl studs, her dark blonde hair pulled up into the high ponytail she had worn every working day since her first job. Square jaw. The little cleft in her chin that her grandmother used to press with a floury thumb.

At six the street door opened at the bottom of the stairs and three sets of feet came up them together.

She heard them before she saw them, which told her something already. They did not come up in a line. They came up the narrow staircase as three men who were used to taking a staircase together and had stopped arranging themselves for it a long time ago, one voice low and carrying on halfway up, a laugh cut off, a pair of feet that took the last steps two at a time and then had to wait on the landing for the other two. She was standing, with her hand on the doorknob, by the time they reached it, and she opened it before anybody knocked.

Three foreheads, each with its smudge of ash.

She had seen their names for four months and their faces for none of it, and she sorted them as she sorted every room she walked into, which was fast and silently and from the outside in.

The first through the door was the tallest, and he took his hat off as he came, a soft gray felt that he held by the crown. Gray flannel suit, a knitted tie the color of claret, a long camel overcoat open over it, the kind that is made for a man and not bought for him. Forty, she thought, or a little over. A long, mild, clean-shaven face, hazel eyes, a wide mouth, and fine dark-brown hair that fell straight across his forehead and lay over the ash so that the cross showed through it in pieces. He was narrow at the shoulder and broad through the hips, and he stood very straight, as if somebody had told him once to stand straight and he had believed them. He said, "Good evening," to her, and then, "You must be Miss Hartmann. Carlo says you've made him punctual," and she knew the voice before he had finished: the careful, upright hand at the bottom of the denial letter. Arturo Falcone. The eldest; she had worked that out from the way Carlo talked about him, as if he were weather. She put him down as the one in charge before he had got his coat off, because he was the eldest and because everybody always did, and she did not notice that those were the only two reasons she had.

The second was the one who had kept talking on the stairs, and he had stopped the moment the door opened. He was a little shorter than the first, and darker: deep olive skin, black hair, straight and heavy, worn down to the jaw and tucked behind his ears. A navy suit under a dark quilted jacket that did not go with it and that he did not seem to care did not go with it, a white shirt open at the neck, no tie. His chest was flat under the waistcoat, almost hollow, and his hands were long and narrow and perfectly still at his sides. He looked at her, and then at the room, and then at the file cabinet between the doors, and then back at her, and he did not say anything at all. She did not have his name yet. She had it a moment later, when Carlo came to his own door and said, "Raffaele," before he said anything to either of the other two.

She noted that. She noted it the way she noted which of her mother's friends was handed the good cup.

The third came in last because he had been the one waiting on the landing, and he came in still moving. He was the smallest of the three and the youngest, a light, quick man in a charcoal suit that had been to court today and come out the other side of it with its jacket unbuttoned and the sleeves of the shirt turned back twice underneath. Fair skin, freckles across a snub nose, a close sandy beard, gray eyes, and sandy-brown hair that was short at the sides and long at the front and had fallen over one eyebrow and smeared the ash on his forehead sideways into a gray thumb-stroke. He looked like somebody who had been sitting still since nine that morning and had taken it personally. He said, "Hi," to her, flatly, and then, after a second, "Gianni," as though he had decided she might as well know.

G. Russo. The signature running off the line.

"There's coffee," she said, "if anybody wants it. It's from four o'clock."

"Then nobody wants it," Carlo said. "Come in. Gianni, there are only two chairs. Take hers."

"I'll take the one out there," Gianni said, and did, the visitor's chair at the side of her desk, where clients sat while she found them a pen. He turned it a quarter round so he could see through the open door into Carlo's room, dropped into it, and put one ankle on his other knee, and then took it off again.

The other two went through. The door stayed open. It always did.

She sat down at her desk because there was nothing else to do with herself, and pulled the closing letters back under the lamp, and did not read them. It was not her meeting. It was Carlo's, with three men of his own family, about a case of his that she kept the file for, and the arithmetic of what she was allowed to hear in that office had been settled in her first week: anything said with the door open was hers to know and not hers to repeat. She had found that a perfectly good rule. She had worked under worse.

Through the door she watched them sort themselves. Arturo took the left-hand client chair and sat very upright in it with his hat on his knee. Raffaele did not sit at once. He took off the quilted jacket and then, after a moment, his suit jacket under it, and hung the suit jacket on the back of the right-hand chair, squaring its shoulders over the chair's shoulders with those long fingers, and only then sat down in his shirtsleeves and waistcoat as if the room were his own kitchen.

They talked about the motion. She could follow most of it and did not try to follow the rest. Carlo did the talking, as Carlo always did, warm and quick and turning every point over twice to show them the underside. Arturo asked careful questions in a careful voice, and once, when Carlo said the word denial, she saw a faint color come up across his forehead under the hair, under the ash, and go down again. Raffaele said almost nothing. Twice Carlo stopped in the middle of a sentence and looked at him, and Raffaele moved one hand on the arm of the chair an inch, and Carlo went on in a slightly different direction. Neither time did Arturo seem to notice. Neither time did Raffaele seem to want anybody to.

And beside her, the whole time, Gianni's knee went.

It went up and down under the edge of her desk, quick and light, the heel of his good shoe never quite touching the floor. He would catch it and stop it with a hand flat on his thigh, and it would hold for half a minute, and then it would go again. He did not seem to know he was doing it. He was listening with his whole face turned to the door and his jaw set, and when Carlo said the tenant's statement was the only thing in the file worth stealing, he said, "Then it shouldn't be in a file," loud enough to go through the doorway, and the room inside went quiet.

"It's in a locked cabinet," Carlo said mildly.

"It's in a cabinet," Gianni said, "on Atwells, on the second floor, behind a door with your name on it in gold."

Libby looked at the file cabinet. It was gray and dented and it stuck at the third drawer, and the lock on it, as far as she knew, had not been turned since the lease began, because she had never been given the key. She did not say so. Nobody had asked her.

Raffaele said something too low for her to hear. Gianni's knee stopped. It did not start again for nearly a minute, which was the longest she saw it hold all evening.

They were in there forty minutes. At ten to seven Carlo stood up, and the other two stood up with him, and Raffaele took his jacket off the back of the chair and put it on again and then the quilted one over it, without hurrying. Gianni was on his feet before any of them, already at the street door with his hand on the knob.

Arturo came out first. He stopped at her desk and said, "Thank you for staying, Miss Hartmann. It's late for you," in a voice so kind that she found herself absurdly close to telling him it was not, and then he put his hat on and went down the stairs.

Raffaele did not follow him straight away.

He stopped at the corner of her desk, on the far side from where Gianni had been sitting, and looked down at it: the blotter, the lamp, the closing letters, the green pad open beside her right hand with tomorrow written in it. He looked at it longer than people usually looked at a desk. Then he looked at her.

"Sunday," he said. "You'll come up to the house. One o'clock."

It took her a moment. She knew which house; everybody on the hill knew which house. Carlo talked about the Sunday table the way other men talked about their unit in the army, with affection and a certain amount of fatigue. Twenty at lunch, he had said once, as if it were a temperature. She had never been asked to it, and she had never expected to be asked to it, any more than she would have expected to be asked to the bank's board meeting because she kept her checking account there.

"Me," she said.

"You."

"Should I bring something?"

"Bring nothing."

At the street door, she saw Gianni turn his head.

She took the pen out of the spiral at the top of the pad, and then she put it down, and she squared the closing letters against the edge of the blotter, both hands, until their corners met. She did not do it for the letters. She had done it all her life, before saying a thing that needed saying, and she had stopped being embarrassed by it at about fifteen.

"Why?" she said.

Raffaele looked at her as if it were a perfectly reasonable question and one he had already decided not to answer.

"Because you're asked," he said, and went.

End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.

Get the e-book