A sample from
Line Item
By half past four Doug Prentiss had decided it was a rough day at the bid desk and nothing worse, and he went on believing it right up until he found Pilcher at the far corner of Kiernan's desk, waiting to tell him otherwise.
He told himself this in the elevator, and again in the corridor, past the plotter alcove where somebody's half-sheets were curling off the tray, past the model shop where Corrigan was rolling the Ashburn set into tubes with the air of a man who had been handed a project on a Monday and wanted it known he did not mind. Doug lifted a coffee at him. Corrigan lifted a tube back.
He had two coffees. He nearly always had two. One for the walk and one for when he got there, and if anybody asked he said they were both his, which was true often enough to count.
Kiernan's door was open, which he took as a good sign. A shut door at four-thirty on a bid day was a conversation, and an open one was a briefing, and Doug was very good at briefings.
"Nadine." He came in shoulder first, because his hands were full. "Before you say anything. I've talked to three people this afternoon and every one of them says the same thing, which is that January bids on public work run hot. Steel's guessing. Mechanical's guessing. Half of what we're looking at is some estimator in Schaumburg padding for a tariff that may never happen, and if we—"
He stopped, because she was not looking at him. She was looking at her desk.
She had the bid tab out. Not the PDF the Park District had sent round at ten past two, which Doug had opened on his phone in the lobby and closed again rather quickly. She had printed it and laid it out by hand, the way she laid out a set: the cover sheet, then the bidders in the order they'd been read, then the low bid broken down by division, each page squared to the edge of the one before. Her silver bob swung forward as she bent over it. The reading glasses were on her nose, not on the chain, which meant she had been reading for some time.
And Pilcher was there.
Doug had not seen him from the door. He was standing at the far corner of the desk by the window, where the north light came in flat and gray off the river, and he had been so still that the room had arranged itself without him. He held a single sheet in a black bulldog clip, with a thicker sheaf under it. Pale blue shirt, a dark V-neck over it against the cold that came off the glass in January. Steel-gray hair cut so short and so even it looked like the same haircut Doug had seen on him eleven years ago. He was clean-shaven, of course. Doug had never once seen him otherwise.
"Pilcher," Doug said warmly, as if they were old friends, which in a sense they were. They had sat at the same table perhaps two hundred times. "I didn't know you were in on this. Coffee? It's the second one, it's still hot."
"No. Thank you."
"You sure? I can't drink both of them. Well. I can."
"I don't drink coffee after two."
Doug waited for the rest of the sentence, the small social thing people added, or I'm up all night, doctor's orders, I'm a lightweight. It did not come. Pilcher had answered what he was asked, and he had stopped.
"Sit down, Doug," Kiernan said, without looking up. There was one chair on the visitor side of the desk, and nobody was in it, and the drafting stool in the corner had never in recorded history been sat on by anybody. Doug sat. He put one of the coffees on the only bare corner of the desk, and Kiernan moved it four inches off the bid tab with one finger.
"Thirteen million, five hundred and sixteen thousand," she said. "Low bid. Against twelve-four."
"I know."
"Nine percent."
"I know, Nadine. That's why I'm saying, if you look at the spread on the—"
"I've looked at the spread." She turned a page and squared it. "Six bidders. The low bid is not the outlier. The low bid is the good news."
Doug opened his mouth and closed it again. He set his coffee down beside the first one and pushed his glasses up into his hair, which was where they lived, and leaned back in the chair the way he leaned back in any chair he meant to be persuasive from.
"Okay," he said. "Okay. So it's real. Then we do what we always do. We sit down with the low bidder, we walk through it, we find where they've padded, we give a little on the finishes and they give a little on the—"
"It's public work," Pilcher said.
Doug turned his head. Pilcher was not looking at him. He was looking at the bid tab, upside down from where he stood, reading it anyway.
"The Park District can't negotiate with the low bidder," Pilcher said. "It's a sealed bid. They award it as bid, or they reject all bids and put it out again."
It was not said unkindly. It was not said any way at all. It was simply true, and Doug knew it was true, had known it for thirty years, and had been about to talk past it anyway because the talking was how he got anywhere.
He felt the heat start at the back of his neck. He was fifty-six years old and fair-skinned and it still did that.
"Right," he said. "Sure. I know that. I was—" He laughed at himself, because that was the move, and because it was funny. "I was hoping nobody in the room would say it out loud."
Kiernan took her glasses off her nose and let them hang. Not dropped. Just hung.
"Gloria Haddad rang me at ten past three," she said. "Her office is rejecting all bids. She is prepared to re-advertise in the February cycle with the same six on the list, if there is a revised set and a savings narrative in front of her by Tuesday the second. If there isn't, she re-advertises it as drawn in the spring, with a deduct list her own people will write. You know what that means."
Doug knew what that meant. It meant somebody in the capital-projects office with a red pen and no feeling for the building would go down his sheets taking things out by the square foot. It meant the clerestory. It meant the roof.
"Tuesday the second," he said. "That's three weeks."
"That's three weeks," Kiernan agreed.
"To find a million dollars."
"One million, one hundred and sixteen thousand," Pilcher said.
Doug turned and looked at him again. This time Pilcher looked back. His eyes were gray, or gray-blue, the color of the window behind him. His face did nothing at all. Doug was a man who could get a smile out of a parking attendant in under ten seconds, and he had a sudden and specific awareness that he was not going to get one here.
"Thank you," Doug said. "That's very helpful."
"You're welcome."
There was a pause in which Doug genuinely could not tell whether he had been teased. He decided he had not. He decided, a beat later, that he was not sure.
Kiernan held out her hand without turning around, and Pilcher stepped forward and put the bulldog clip into it. Two steps, a straight arm, back to the corner. He moved like a man who rode a bike a long way every day, which Doug happened to know he did, because the bike lived in the basement by the freight elevator and on wet mornings the whole basement smelled of chain oil and somebody's good wool overcoat. Lean, narrow through the waist. Doug had known that for years the way you know the color of a colleague's car. He noticed that he was noticing it now, and filed it, and looked at the paper.
Kiernan laid the summary sheet on top of the bid tab, square to it, and turned it to face him.
One page. A title block. Two lines of the job: Halloran Park Fieldhouse — Chicago Park District — Bid Review. A line with the gap on it. Under that, numbered, the four largest single-item savings in order, with a dollar figure to the right of each one.
The first line was his roof.
1. Gymnasium roof: exposed glulam to steel joist and acoustic deck. $412,000.
He had known it would be. Any honest list would start there. It was the biggest single thing in the building that was not strictly needed to keep the rain off a basketball court, and he had fought for it through schematics and fought for it through DD and won, because the Park District's own people had stood under the mock-up bay at the fabricator's shop in Wisconsin and gone quiet the way people went quiet in churches. Big laminated timbers, honey-colored, running the width of the gym. A building for kids who had never been in a building that looked like somebody had wanted them in it.
He did not read the other three lines. He made himself read the first one twice and then he looked up.
"It's a schematic list," he said. "Right? This is your fast pass."
"It's from the bid," Pilcher said. "Not the schematic. The low bidder's breakout by division, against my backup."
"So it's solid."
"It's the number."
Doug waited again for something more and again there wasn't any. He found that he was smiling, a little, at nothing. It was a new experience, being answered so exactly. It was like putting your foot down for a stair that wasn't there and finding that the floor was perfectly level.
"Okay," Doug said. He turned back to Kiernan and put both forearms on the edge of her desk. He had his sleeves shoved up to the elbow; he always did. "Okay. So here's what I think. I take this, I take the weekend, I go through the set with my people, I come back Monday with a package that—"
"No," Kiernan said.
He stopped.
"You'll do it with Mr. Pilcher." She put her glasses back on her nose, which meant she was about to read something to him off a page that was not there. "You're the lead on this job. You are going to remain the lead on this job. There is one name on the cover of that set and it's yours, and when Gloria Haddad wants to know who's answering for this building on the second of February, it will be you, at that table. I'm not changing that."
"I wasn't asking you to."
"I know. I'm telling you anyway, so that you hear the next part properly." She looked over the glasses at him. "Mr. Pilcher's job is to get you there. You'll work down his list. In order. Every evening, if that's what it takes, and it's going to be what it takes. You will not take it home and come back on Monday with a package. You'll sit at a table with the man who knows what things cost."
Doug looked at Pilcher. Pilcher was looking at the window.
"Every evening," Doug said.
"The conference room is empty after six. The radiator works about half the time. I'll have somebody look at it." She would not have somebody look at it; nobody had ever had somebody look at it. "Three weeks, Doug. Bring me something I can put in front of a client."
He sat back. The coffee on the corner of the desk had stopped steaming. Out the window the lake was somewhere behind the weather, a darker band of gray under a lighter one, and down on Wacker the five o'clock traffic was already backing up toward the bridge.
There was a version of this meeting in which he made it all right. He could see it; he had been in it a thousand times. He would say something self-deprecating about old dogs and new tricks, and something gracious about how glad he was to have the best numbers man in the city in his corner, and he would stand up and clap Pilcher on the shoulder on the way out, and by the time he reached the corridor the whole thing would be a story he was telling about himself. Kiernan would roll her eyes. Pilcher would—
He did not know what Pilcher would do. He could not remember the last time he had not known.
"Fine," Doug said. "Good. Tomorrow?"
"Six o'clock," said Pilcher.
"Six works. I'll bring—" He was going to say coffee. "I'll bring the set."
"I have the set."
"The full set? The details too? There's a lot of sheets in that set nobody—"
"All of it."
Doug nodded slowly. He picked up both coffees. He stood, and because he was six foot two and the visitor chair was low, standing took a moment, and in that moment he looked down at the summary in its clip one more time and saw the bottom of the page, which he had not looked at before.
Kiernan had printed it from an email. The header was still at the top of the sheet in small gray type, sent at 3:52 p.m., and at the bottom, under the four lines and the total, was the signature block.
Leonard Pilcher Cost Estimator Voss & Kiernan
Leonard.
He had known that, presumably. It must have been on a hundred emails. He had never once read it.
"Thank you, Nadine," he said, and went to the door. At the door he turned, because he could not help it. "Pilcher. One question."
Pilcher looked at him.
"The low bidder. Who is it?"
"Halvorsen Brothers. Out of Elk Grove."
"Are they any good?"
"They built the Kedzie branch library on time and eleven thousand dollars under the contingency."
"So they're good."
"They built the Kedzie branch on time and eleven thousand under the contingency."
Doug laughed out loud. He couldn't help that either. Kiernan, at her desk, made a small sound that might have been her clearing her throat.
End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.