Stick the Landing

The pitcher's shoulder told Reyna Holloway its whole life story in the first thirty seconds, the way shoulders always did.

"You've been throwing through it," she said, thumbs finding the knotted seam where his infraspinatus had given up negotiating with his rotator cuff and gone to open war. "Six weeks, maybe eight."

On the table, Darius Webb — twenty years old, ninety-four on the radar gun, right arm currently worth more than the building they were standing in — made a sound halfway between a laugh and a confession. "Coach said you'd know."

"Coach was right." She worked the tissue slowly, letting the heat of her palms do the first round of arguing. Under the fluorescent hum of Peachtree Performance Physio, treatment room two smelled like eucalyptus gel and clean linen and the faint industrial lemon of whatever they mopped with, and none of it covered the specific truth her hands were reading: a joint being asked for more than it had left to give, by a body too young and too hungry to hear the answer. "You want the good news or the bad news?"

"Good."

"It's not structural yet." She felt him sag with relief, and dug in a little harder, because relief made people stupid. "Bad news: yet is doing a lot of work in that sentence. You keep pretending this is normal soreness, and in six months some surgeon in Buckhead is going to buy a boat with your labrum."

"That specific, huh."

"I've seen the boat."

He laughed, then hissed as she found the worst of it, the deep trigger point tucked under the scapula's edge where throwers hid their sins. She held the pressure and counted his breathing and did the thing she was good at, the thing they paid her for: she read a body like a box score and told it the truth with her hands.

Nobody at the clinic knew what her own right shoulder said. That was the deal she'd made with herself two years ago, and she kept it the way she'd kept every deal with herself since she was six years old and learning that the beam didn't care how you felt about it. The torn labrum, the two surgeries, the titanium anchor holding the whole arrangement together like a bad compromise — it all sat quiet under her scrub top, a phantom career that ached in the exact shape of a Yurchenko double she would never throw again.

It was aching now. It always ached when she worked throwers. Sympathy pains, Nakia called it, which was wrong. Sympathy was for other people. This was more like a dog hearing a whistle pitched too high for the rest of the room.

"So what do I do?" Darius asked, when she'd finished breaking up the worst of the adhesions and he was sitting up, flexing the arm with the wondering look they all got, like she'd handed him back something he'd assumed was gone for good.

"You tell your coach the truth. You throw the recovery schedule I'm about to print, not the one in your head. And when it hurts —" she held his eyes, because this was the part none of them heard the first time — "it's not a test. Pain isn't a test you pass by ignoring it. It's information."

"That what they taught you in massage school?"

"No," Reyna said, and smiled her dry professional smile, the one that closed doors so smoothly people rarely noticed a door had been there at all. "I learned that one the expensive way."

She printed his protocol, booked his follow-up, and sent him back out into the bright late-May afternoon with his multimillion-dollar arm and his whole unbroken future, and if there was a version of her that wanted to grab him by the collar and say listen to me, I was you, I was better than you, and it can all be gone between the springboard and the mat — that version stayed where she kept her, behind the door with the smile.

Four more clients. A marathoner's calves, a tennis elbow, a weekend warrior who'd discovered CrossFit at forty-five and was paying the subscription fee in fascia. She was good with all of them, easy, funny in the dosed-out way that made people relax under her hands. Kelsey at the front desk called her the closer — give Reyna the difficult ones, she doesn't rattle. True. You didn't rattle a woman who'd competed on a stress-fractured ankle at fourteen. You couldn't reach the part of her that rattled. That was the whole design of the machine.

At six she cleaned her room, restocked her gels, and stood for a moment at the window watching the parking lot go gold. Two years at this clinic. Close enough to sport to smell the chalk on other people's lives, far enough that nobody ever asked her body for anything harder than an eight-hour shift. Sports massage was the perfect distance from gymnastics: adjacent, useful, safe. A viewing gallery with a salary.

The hunger didn't have a name yet. That was the problem with it. It sat under her sternum through the drive home, through the parking deck and the stairs to her apartment — third floor, she took stairs like other people took vitamins — and it was still sitting there when she'd showered and eaten standing up at the counter, a chicken bowl she didn't taste, and it was there when she poured the single glass of wine that was all she ever poured, discipline outlasting the sport by two years and counting.

Her apartment was tidy the way hotel rooms were tidy. One shelf of medals she couldn't display and couldn't throw away, boxed in the closet. One framed photo out: her and Nakia at eleven and twelve, leotards and gap-toothed grins, chalk to the elbows, before either of them knew what the sport would take in exchange for what it gave.

She sat on the couch with her laptop and told herself she was going to look at continuing-education courses. It was almost funny, how thin the lie had gotten. Three weeks of the same lie, worn down to tissue.

She opened her email and scrolled to the message she had not archived, not deleted, and not answered, which was its own kind of answer.

The Obsidian Club — Membership Application: Approved.

The email was two paragraphs long and read like it had been written by someone with excellent posture. No exclamation points. No welcome-to-the-family. Her application had been reviewed and approved; the next step, at her convenience and only at her convenience, was an intake appointment — a conversation and a written limits document, completed in person, before any participation in club activities. There were open intake hours Friday evening. A held space, the last line said, worked best when it was entered honestly, and honesty took longer than a form. They looked forward to taking the time.

At her convenience. Nothing in the email pushed. That was the thing that kept getting her — she'd expected, at some level she wasn't proud of, something that would let her sneer and close the tab. Something velvet-tacky, something breathless. Instead the whole thing was written in the calm, margin-noted voice of an institution that had nothing to prove, and it had been sitting in her inbox for three weeks like a patient teacher who knew she'd come back with the assignment eventually.

She'd applied at 2 a.m. on a Tuesday in April. That was the version of events she told herself: 2 a.m., a glass and a half of wine — the one night the discipline slipped — some algorithm's idea of what a woman who read what she read and lingered where she lingered might want, an application filled out in a fugue of honesty she'd been calling a whim ever since.

It hadn't been a whim. She could still remember the specific weight of every answer.

What brings you to us? the application had asked, and 2 a.m. Reyna, who was apparently the only honest woman in the building, had typed: I spent twenty years being asked for everything my body could give. Nobody has asked since. I want to be asked again, by someone who knows what they're asking for.

She'd stared at that sentence for ten minutes before hitting submit. She'd been staring at it, one way or another, ever since.

Reyna clicked through to the intake portal — she had the sequence memorized by now, three clicks, she could have done it with her eyes closed, which was itself a piece of information she declined to examine — and scrolled, as she always did, to the preliminary limits inventory. Pages of it, thorough as a pre-op questionnaire, which she found perversely soothing. Restraint. Sensation. Power exchange. And then the section her cursor always ended up in, the way a tongue ends up in the gap where the tooth was pulled.

Impact play. Please indicate interest and experience: open hand — paddle — strap — flogger — crop — cane.

Cane.

Her cursor hovered over the word, and the word looked back.

She could justify the others. Open hand, sure — that was practically a rom-com. Strap, fine, that was just intensity, and intensity was her mother tongue; she'd been fluent in intensity while her classmates were still learning to spell it. But cane was not a mood or a curiosity. Cane was precision. Cane was the thin white-hot line, the implement that didn't blur, the one that asked you to hold still and count and choose it, stroke by stroke, with nowhere to hide inside the sensation. She knew exactly why she wanted it. That was the problem. Wanting it meant admitting what the wanting was made of, and every time she got this far — cursor on the word, pulse tapping in her wrists like a metronome set too fast — the same cold voice asked the question that had been running her life since the second surgery:

What kind of woman misses pain?

Not the sport. Everyone understood missing the sport. Missing the crowds, the flight, the four square inches of beam that had been the one place the world made sense. That grief was legible; people sent cards for that grief. But this — lying awake missing the specific clarity of a body pushed to its edge and held there, missing being demanded of, missing the coach's voice that asked for one more when there was nothing left and the strange bright peace of finding it anyway — there was no card for that. There was just a woman alone on a tidy couch, twenty-six years old, wanting a thing she couldn't say out loud in a room with nobody in it.

Her shoulder ached, phantom and faithful.

Friday's open intake hours glowed at the bottom of the portal. Tomorrow. A button that said, with that same infuriating institutional calm, Confirm appointment, and under it, in small type that somebody had chosen deliberately, a single line: You may cancel or reschedule at any time. The door opens both ways.

The door opens both ways. She read it twice. It was, she decided, either the most manipulative sentence ever written or the first true thing anyone had said to her in two years, and she was suddenly, furiously tired of being a woman who couldn't tell the difference.

Two years of being fine. Two years of the viewing gallery and the closed-door smile and the single glass of wine. Two years of a body that had been trained since age six to give everything on command, standing in an empty gym of a life, waiting for a command that never came.

It's not a test, she'd told the pitcher, five hours and a whole life ago. It's information.

Well. She was drowning in information. Time to see what it was trying to say.

Reyna set down the wine, and clicked before the cold voice could clear its throat — appointment confirmed, Friday, 7 p.m. — and then she sat very still in her quiet apartment, heart going like she'd just landed something, palms flat on her thighs, breathing the way she'd been taught to breathe before a routine.

Chalk up, Holloway, she thought, with the ghost of a grin her old squad would have recognized and nobody in her current life ever saw. Salute the judges.

The email confirmation arrived with a soft chime: We look forward to meeting you. She believed, God help her, that they meant it.

End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.

Get the e-book