A sample from

The Bride Who Wrote Back

> Gilt Creek, Colorado, June 2, 1884. > Miss Beckwith, The branch train is due in at a quarter past two. I will be on the platform. I am the tall one, and I will have your picture in my hand, so that you will know me before I know you. Mrs. Kuster asks me to tell you the hotel has a bathtub. E. Strayer.

Abigail Beckwith had written eleven letters to the man who would be waiting on the Gilt Creek platform, and he would be holding a picture of her sister.

The branch coach was narrower than a schoolroom aisle, and on the last grade it leaned so far into each curve that Abigail kept one hand flat on the window sash, as if she could hold it upright by good intentions. The creek ran below the track in a white rush. Above it the slopes went up in dark spruce and pale stands of aspen, and above those the mountains still carried snow in their creases, though it was the twenty-sixth of June and in Ohio the wheat would be heading.

She had his letter in her lap. She did not need to read it. She had it by heart, as she had all eleven, but holding it gave her hands an occupation that was not pulling at her gloves.

So that you will know me before I know you.

He had meant it kindly. He had meant that she should have the first look, and the first chance to change her mind, and she had loved him a little for thinking of it. He could not have known how exactly the sentence would come true. She would know him. He would know a girl in a cabinet photograph who was at that moment in Licking County, choosing between two patterns of muslin for a wedding dress of her own.

Abigail went over it once more.

She had gone over it since Pueblo, where the Santa Fe set her down and the narrow gauge took her up. She had gone over it at the junction, in the hour on the bench while they made up the branch train, and she had gone over it through the long climb since, the way she went over a lesson she meant to give to a room of forty children who would rather be fishing. First the plain statement. Then the evidence. Then the question, and then stop talking. Eight years in a one-room school had taught her that the teacher who went on talking after the question had been asked was a teacher who was afraid of the answer.

The plain statement was this: I am not the girl in your picture.

The evidence was this. In January her sister Minnie, who was twenty and bored and had found the Matrimonial News folded inside a parcel from the dry-goods store, had answered an advertisement placed by a Mrs. Kuster of Gilt Creek on behalf of a mine superintendent, thirty-four, of good habits. Minnie had sent one letter and one cabinet card from the studio in Newark, and inside the month she had become engaged to the Prentiss boy from the next farm and forgotten Colorado entirely. His reply came addressed to Miss Beckwith. Abigail had opened it at the kitchen table, meaning to write two civil lines of explanation, and she had read it twice instead. It was the most interesting letter anyone had ever sent to their house. She had answered it. She had signed it Miss Beckwith, which was true, and she had not written Abigail, which was the whole of her evasion, and she had gone on not writing it for ten more letters.

The question she had not settled. Every version of it sounded like begging or like a dare, and she was not willing to do either in front of strangers.

Across the aisle a mining engineer with a sample case between his boots had given up his newspaper and was frankly watching her rehearse. Abigail realized her lips were moving. She stopped them. He touched his hat brim and went back to his paper, and she was obliged to him for that.

She was twenty-six years old. If she had written her own advertisement, she knew what the columns would have made her: Age twenty-six. Height five feet eight. White, American born, of Connecticut Yankee stock, Ohio raised. Hair brown. Eyes hazel. A schoolteacher. Object, matrimony. The columns had no line for the rest of it. They had no line for a woman who was taller than most of the men she met and had stopped stooping to make them comfortable, or for the plum wool traveling dress she had saved two terms for and had fitted in Newark by a dressmaker who said, with her mouth full of pins, that a figure like hers was wasted on a schoolroom. The bodice buttoned close from the high collar to the point of the waist, and across the bust it fitted closer than Abigail had asked for. She had let it stand. The skirt was drawn back over a small bustle in the new way and fell long to her boots. Her hair was up in its coil under a small plum hat with one gray feather, and she had pinned it at the junction with more pins than it needed.

Inside her left glove, against her palm, was the money order he had sent in May for her fare. It was made out to Miss Beckwith, and she had not cashed it. She had come on her own savings, by her own ticket. The paper had gone soft from four days of being held.

The coach came round the shoulder of the mountain, and the valley opened.

It was wider than she had pictured. He had written that it was a long green floor with the mountains for walls, and she had taken that for a man's attempt at poetry, but it was only accurate. Hay meadows ran flat along the creek, cut by bright ditches. Cattle stood in them. Up the side gulches she could see the gray and yellow scars of the mines, a few buildings clinging there, a tall stack with a thread of smoke. The town itself sat at the foot of it all, a single long street of raw board fronts with two brick buildings standing among them like the two children in a class who had come with clean collars. A frame courthouse with a cupola. A church. The depot at the near end, and across the yard from it a two-story frame building that must be Mrs. Kuster's hotel.

The brakes took hold. The coach shuddered along its length and slowed.

Then she saw the platform, and her rehearsal went out of her like air out of a bellows.

There were a great many people on it. There were more people on it than a Thursday train could possibly require. Men, chiefly. Men in shirtsleeves and vests and the dust of the gulches, men in town coats, men who had plainly come straight from a shift with their hats pushed back. There were a few women among them. At the very front, in black silk, stood a broad gray-haired woman with her hands folded at her waist like someone at a christening, and Abigail knew without being told that it was Mrs. Kuster, and that Mrs. Kuster had told the town.

At the far end of the platform, past the baggage car, a big freight wagon stood with a team of mules in harness. Two young men held the leaders by their headstalls, keeping them clear of the crowd. A third man, older, broad through the back, in a flat-crowned hat, had already let down the wagon's tailboard.

And in the middle of the platform, a little apart, a man stood with a card in his hand.

She did not need the card to pick him out. He had said he was the tall one, and he was. He stood a head over the men nearest him, and he was broad with it, heavy through the shoulders under a dark sack suit, his Stetson held against his leg in one hand. His hair was dark, almost black, cut short and pushed back off his forehead. He wore a short beard, close trimmed. He was looking down at the photograph, and then up at the windows of the coach, and down again, as if he were checking a sum.

What was the first sentence, when every sentence she owned was true?

The coach stopped. The brakeman put down the step. The engineer with the sample case stood aside for her, and Abigail took up her carpetbag herself, because she had carried it from Ohio and did not see why she should stop now, and stepped down onto the boards of Gilt Creek.

She felt the platform look at her. It was a physical thing, like stepping out of shade. She had been looked at by men before. She was tall and she was made the way she was made, and men on the street in Newark had looked twice, and some of them three times. This was forty men looking at once, and then at the card he held, and then back at her. She heard someone near the front say, quite clearly, "Well, that's not her." Someone else said, "Hush."

At the far end of the platform the older freighter had swung her trunk down from the baggage car by its handles. He was the only man there not watching her. He set it on his wagon, squared it with the flat of his hand, and turned back for the hatbox.

Mr. Strayer had looked up from the card. His eyes were gray. That had not been in any letter. He opened his mouth, and she knew he was going to say Miss Beckwith, and that if he said it first she would never get the rest out.

"Mr. Strayer," she said. "I am Miss Beckwith. I am not the one you are holding."

The platform went entirely still. Even the mules seemed to attend.

"That is my sister Minnie," Abigail said. Her voice came out level, which surprised her. It was her schoolroom voice, the one that carried to the back bench. "She wrote you the first letter in January and she sent you that picture. She has been engaged since the end of that month to a young man at home, and she will be married in October, and she has not thought about Colorado since. Your reply came to the house addressed to Miss Beckwith. I opened it. I meant to write and explain, and I wrote back instead, and I went on writing. Every letter you have had since February was mine. All eleven. I signed them Miss Beckwith because it was the truth, and because I never found the sentence that would explain the rest of it. I have been looking for that sentence since Pueblo. This is the best I could do."

She stopped. She did not ask the question. She found she did not need to. It stood on the platform between them without her help.

He looked down at the photograph. Minnie looked up out of it, small and fair and pleased with herself, in the lace collar she had borrowed from their mother. Then he looked at Abigail. He took his time about it. He looked at her face, and at the carpetbag in her hand, and at the height of her, and back at her face, and she made herself hold still and be looked at. She had resolved on the train that she would not drop her eyes. She did not drop them.

He had written, in his fourth letter, that he was not a handsome man and that she should not come expecting one. She had read that line by lamplight and had believed it, and she had come out regardless. Now she corrected it in her head the way she would correct a slate. It was not a lie. It was a careless choice of word. His nose had been broken once and set a little off true, and his face was broad and square and weathered brown above the beard, and nobody would have painted him. But handsome was a small word for a small idea, and the face in front of her was not small in any direction.

He held the photograph out to her.

Abigail looked at it. She did not take it at once.

"This belongs to a girl who is going to marry somebody else," he said. His voice was lower than she had imagined, and slower, and it did not carry the way hers did. The men nearest leaned in to hear it. "It ought to go home to her. Will you send it?"

She took the card. It was warm from his hand. She put it in her reticule, beside his letter, and drew the string.

"Yes," she said. "I'll send it."

Across the platform Mrs. Kuster unfolded her hands and folded them again the other way, which seemed to Abigail a considerable event.

He turned the Stetson once in his fingers. He was a man, she could see, who started slowly. She had known that from the letters. His first lines were always short, and then on the second page he would forget himself and write about the hawks over the shaft house or a pump that would not prime, and the letter would go on for six pages and end abruptly, as though he had looked up and found it was dark.

"The letter about the spelling bee," he said. "The miller's girl who won it on chrysanthemum and then cried in front of the whole township. That was yours?"

It was the fifth letter. She had written it at midnight with her feet on the fender and had nearly not sent it, because it ran to nine pages and did nothing but describe a schoolroom.

"Yes," she said. "That was mine. She cried because she had expected to lose. She had brought a handkerchief for losing, and she had nothing ready for the other thing."

Something happened at the corner of his mouth. It did not get as far as a smile. It looked like a man setting down a load he had been carrying for some distance.

At the end of the platform the freighter had finished with the hatbox. He came along the boards toward them, unhurried, taking off his hat as he came, and the men parted for him without being asked. He was perhaps forty-five, with gray in his moustache and a face browned past any color the sun could add to it. He stopped a respectful distance off and spoke to Mr. Strayer, though his eyes went to her.

"Your trunk and box are on my wagon, ma'am. Mr. Strayer, they will stay on it until somebody tells me where they go."

"Thank you, Mr. Archuleta," said Mr. Strayer.

Mr. Archuleta put his hat back on and went back to his mules. Abigail watched him go and thought that in a town where every other man had stopped to stare, the man most worth noticing was the one who had gone on working.

When she turned back, Mr. Strayer was still looking at her. The depot clock above the telegraph window said nineteen minutes past two. Behind her, the engine let off steam with a long sigh, and the brakeman began to swing the coach doors shut.

"I have eleven letters signed Miss Beckwith," he said. "I'd like to know the rest of it. Your name. All of it."

Abigail looked up at him. He was perhaps seven inches taller than she was, and she was not used to looking up at anyone. She did not mind it.

"Why all of it?" she said.

"Because that's what goes on the license," said Elias Strayer, "and I want it right."

The platform let out its breath. Somebody near the back laughed, not unkindly, and somebody else said "Hush" again, to no effect at all.

Abigail drew off her left glove. The money order fell from her palm, folded small and soft, and she caught it before it reached the boards and held it with the glove in one hand.

"Abigail," she said. "Abigail Ruth Beckwith."

He said it back to her once, under his breath, as if he were writing it down.

End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.

Get the e-book