A sample from

Word for Word

I was forty-six that February, and by four o'clock on the Thursday I knew the chef I had once reviewed out of business was thirty-two. Neither number troubled me at eight. At eight I had a house to sell.

The Courier was lying at the end of the drive when I went out for it, rolled in its plastic sleeve where the boy had thrown it from a moving car. I took it in under my arm without opening it. I had been in Agua Clara for three weeks, in my mother's house in the Cove, and in three weeks I had not put a single thing of hers into a box; I had, however, read every issue of the Courier front to back, which my mother would have found very funny.

Tom Etheridge came up the drive at eight exactly, with a clipboard and a tape measure, and stood in the carport looking up at the beams. He is a stocky man in his fifties with short brown hair and a tan that stops at his collar, and he lets half the casitas in the Cove every season without, as far as anyone knows, ever raising his voice.

"It shows well," he said. "These sixty-one post-and-beams, people drive out from Los Angeles and lose their minds. You'll have interest in a week."

"I'd like it in a week."

"Then we photograph Tuesday." He smiled at me, the smile of a man about to make a reasonable request he has made in a great many kitchens. "Which means we talk about the kitchen."

I had known it would mean that. The kitchen was the reason my mother bought the house, twenty years ago, from a dentist's widow who had never once cooked in it. It runs the whole width of the back: a terrazzo floor the color of oatmeal with chips of green glass in it, birch cabinets to the ceiling, a long counter under a run of pendant lamps, and at the far end a wall of glass doors onto the terrace and the kidney pool. The pool was heated, and in the cold of the morning it gave off a thin steam that the sun had not yet got round to burning away. Beyond it the lemon tree stood against the breeze-block wall, heavy with fruit nobody had picked since spring. The light at eight in this valley tells you the truth about a room before it starts being polite, and it was telling the truth about this one: the cabinet doors had been wiped by the same hand for twenty years, and every surface had something of hers on it.

Tom walked the length of it with the tape measure, and I let him. He measured the counter. He measured the doors. He wrote both numbers down and then stood by the refrigerator, where my mother had kept the corkboard, and looked at the corkboard with the courtesy of a man looking at a stranger's grief.

"Buyers want to see themselves in a kitchen," he said. "Not somebody else. I'd clear the counters. Nothing on the fridge, nothing on the board." He nodded at the green tin at the end of the counter. "And the personal effects."

The personal effects were my mother's recipe cards. There were perhaps four hundred of them in a green tin box with a hinged lid, and she had been writing them since before I was born: in pencil first, then in blue ballpoint, then for the last twenty years in a fountain pen with black ink that she bought at the stationer's in Pasadena and would not buy anywhere else. She had taught fourth grade for thirty-one years. She corrected her own cards the way she corrected spelling tests, without mercy and without embarrassment; when a recipe was wrong, she struck through the wrong part in ink, wrote the right thing beside it, initialed it and dated it. Her lemon chicken, which I had eaten perhaps two hundred times, carried four corrections over twelve years, and the last of them said only, No. More lemon. D.

"I'll take care of the kitchen," I said.

"By Monday?"

"By Monday."

He believed me, because I am a woman who looks as if she means what she says, and because he had another house to see at nine. He told me the photographer would come at ten on Tuesday and that the light would be better then for the living room, and that if I wanted, he knew a woman who did estate clearances and was kind about it. I said I knew how to put things in boxes. He said of course I did, and went.

I did not put anything in a box. I stood at the counter after his car had gone and opened the tin, and read the cards from the front, as if I had not been reading them for three weeks.

I have written five cookbooks with my name on the spine, and for most of my working life I have written a monthly column for Sideboard, which is the food magazine your dentist has in the waiting room; for most of those years I reviewed restaurants for it too, until four years ago, when I stopped. I know what a recipe is. A recipe is a promise and a set of instructions, and the instructions are only as good as the promise is honest. My mother's cards were the most honest documents I had ever read. She had been wrong in them hundreds of times, and every time she had said so, in ink, in her own kitchen, and signed it.

I sat on the stool at the end of the counter in a silk blouse and wide linen trousers I had no business wearing to clear a kitchen, my reading glasses on and my hair loose because there was no one to keep it up for, and I caught myself in the black glass of the oven door: a woman with my mother's hips and my mother's shoulders and a good deal more bosom than my mother ever had, sitting the way a woman sits who eats well and has never once been sorry for it. I looked fine. I looked better than fine. It was the first time in three weeks I had noticed.

By eleven the light had gone flat and white across the terrace, and I had read as far as the soups.

Margo Kittredge came at three, when the wind had come up off the pass and set the palms along the street clattering like a roomful of typewriters. She parked her white Lexus square in the middle of the drive, the way she parks it everywhere, and came up to the glass doors from the terrace side because she had been coming to this house for twenty years and had never once used the front.

"Greta." She kissed me on the cheek and held me off by the shoulders to look at me. She is sixty-one, trim, with a tennis player's tan and an ash-brown bob that does not move in the wind, and she was wearing an oatmeal linen jacket with the festival's little enamel date palm, gold and green, on the lapel. She has worn a pin like it on every jacket she owns for the eight years she has chaired the festival board. "You look wonderful. You look rested. Have you been swimming?"

"Every morning."

"Your mother would be pleased." She put a thick white folder on the counter, next to the tin. The festival's palm was printed on the front of it. "And I'm about to make you very busy, so enjoy having looked rested."

She had asked me at my mother's memorial, in the club dining room, with a cup of coffee in one hand and my elbow in the other: would I judge the guest-chef competition at the festival, since I would be in town anyway, as a courtesy to the board, and because Dorothy would have liked it. I had said yes in the way one says yes to anything at a memorial. I had not given it a thought since.

"Opening night is tomorrow," Margo said, "which you're excused from, because I need you fresh. Saturday morning is heat one. You know the food hall."

"The one with the mesquite."

"The one with the mesquite. Eight guest chefs, all from valley restaurants, first names only on the boards because two of them have the same last name and aren't related and won't stop telling people. Four cook on Saturday and four on Sunday, two go through from each. Then the second Saturday, the semifinal, four cook, two go through. And the final," she said, with real pleasure, "is the closing dinner at the club."

"In the dining room?"

"In the dining room. I arranged it years ago, because the food hall has no proper seating and I will not have the final eaten off paper plates on a folding table. The finalists cook in the club kitchen. The judges sit at the middle window. Members and the board at the other tables, and the Palm Springs station has said they'll send a camera." She tapped the folder. "Two judges. Each of you scores every plate on a card; the cards are added; I hold a casting vote, and I have never once needed it. You're both paid by the festival, the same fee, which my treasurer thinks is extravagant. You're peers. Neither of you can touch the other's score."

"That's very fair."

"I'm very fair." She opened the folder for me, which she did not need to do. "And you'll like him. He's the draw. When I told the station who we had, the girl on the phone screamed."

The judges' page was the third page in. My own photograph was on the left, an old one from my fourth book in which I am laughing at something the photographer said and which I have never liked. On the right was his.

He was standing in a narrow kitchen in pressed chef's whites with his arms folded and his weight on one hip, and he was grinning at the camera as if it had said something he meant to repeat later. He was Filipino-American, the page said, born and raised in Carson in the South Bay; his skin was a warm golden brown, his eyes were dark, his black hair was thick and straight and had been allowed to grow out and fall forward toward one eyebrow. The grin made him look younger than he was. The forearms did not. Under the photograph, in the festival's green type: DANILO SORIANO, 32. CHEF-OWNER, SABAW, LOS ANGELES. Below that, three lines of biography: a dishwasher at sixteen, a line cook at eighteen, Sabaw three years ago, now one of the hardest tables in the city to book.

The biography did not mention Kalye. I did not need it to.

Six years ago I reviewed his first restaurant, a storefront in Eagle Rock called Kalye, for Sideboard, and I wrote one sentence about it that I was proud of for a month. Kalye closed within the year; I read it in a trade newsletter over breakfast and did not finish the eggs.

What I had told no one was the rest. Two years ago I went to Sabaw alone on a Wednesday, and gave my mother's first name at the door, because it was the first name that came to me and because my own would have changed the evening. I ordered the sinigang. I knew by the third spoonful that I had been wrong about it six years before, not in the details but in the premise; I had judged a broth that is meant to be sour as though sourness were a fault in it, and that is not a matter of taste, that is a matter of not knowing what you are eating. Last autumn I went back, as Dorothy again, and ordered it again, in case I had been sentimental the first time. I had not been. He had been at the pass both nights, bent over the plates with his hair in his eyes, and he had not looked up.

I closed the folder.

"Margo," I said, "I can't do this."

She looked at me with the patience of a woman who has run a hospital and a festival and has heard every sentence that begins that way. "You can do it in your sleep."

"Not with him. Find someone else. There's a woman in Palm Desert who taught at the culinary school; she'd be good, and she'd be glad of the fee. I'll write the paragraph for the program myself about why I withdrew. I'll make it charming."

"Is this about the review?"

"You know about the review."

"Greta, everyone knows about the review. Your mother had it framed in the guest bathroom." She said this kindly, and it was true; it had hung over the towel rail for six years beside my second book's jacket, and I had taken it down my first week here and put it in a drawer. "That was a long time ago. He has a restaurant you can't get into. You haven't reviewed anything in four years. Nobody out here reads Sideboard except the people who read it for you, and your mother's gone."

"He'll remember."

"Then he'll remember." She closed her hand over mine on the folder, briefly; her rings were cold. "The programs are printed. Four thousand of them, on the good paper, with your face on page three next to his. I am not pulping four thousand programs on the day before opening night because two professionals had words in a magazine."

"We didn't have words," I said. "I had them."

She considered that, and me, and decided that it was the kind of thing I said and not the kind of thing that changed anything. "Saturday at eight," she said. "The judges' table is at the end of the hall, under the clock. Wear something you don't mind smelling of smoke." At the glass doors she turned. "Dorothy would have done it, you know. She'd have sat at that table and told the whole hall what she thought and enjoyed every minute."

"She would have," I said. "She'd have been right, too."

Margo laughed, which was the answer she had wanted, and went out across the terrace into the wind. I heard the Lexus door close with that expensive sound and the tires on the gravel, and then only the palms.

The wind dropped a little before five, the way it does, all at once, as if somebody had shut a door at the top of the pass. The pool had stopped steaming in the afternoon heat and would start again when the sun went. I sat at my mother's table with the folder open at the judges' page and the tin open beside it, and my reading glasses on, and I did not get up to start the boxes.

I read his three lines of biography again. I am a careful reader; it is most of what I am paid for. A dishwasher at sixteen. He was thirty-two, which put the dishwashing sixteen years back, and I did the arithmetic I did not need to do and found the year without trying.

End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.

Get the e-book