A sample from
Not Before Him
Alison Godwin told His Honour Judge Prideaux, to his face, that his reason would not hold.
"Your Honour, I'm afraid that reason won't bear the weight Your Honour puts on it."
She had been standing up in this room for six years, and somewhere around the second of them it had stopped being a thing that people noticed and become a thing that people waited for. The usher, on her way to fetch the jury, stopped by the door with her hand on the brass plate. Along the bench Mr Tobin for the Crown, who had just told the judge he was content, sat back to watch. In the public gallery, Ellery's mother — two rows of seats and a carrier bag — sat up straighter.
Court 1 was the old courtroom, high and cold, with pale panelling to shoulder height and a ceiling that took sound and gave it back a quarter of a second late. The jury's note lay open on the desk in front of the judge, his reading glasses beside it. He took the glasses up and folded them, which was what he did when he meant to listen. "Go on, Ms Godwin."
Her client was in the dock behind her: Jason Ellery, twenty-nine, a roofer from Bromyard, accused of going through the back window of a house in Tupsley he had once quoted for guttering. The case against him was a partial fingermark on the outside of a window frame he had, on his own account, stood at a ladder's length from for half an hour eighteen months earlier. He had answered no comment in interview because the duty solicitor at three in the morning had told him to, and the prosecution had not sought an inference from it. On Friday the judge had told the jury, in a careful paragraph, that they must not hold the silence against him. The jury, it appeared, had not been able to let it lie.
"The jury have asked whether they're allowed to consider the fact that Mr Ellery answered no comment in his police interview," she said, "and Your Honour proposes to send them back to the written directions and tell them to decide the case on the evidence they have heard, on the footing that the less said the better, and that short and neutral protects him. The difficulty is the words the evidence you have heard. The interview record went in as an agreed document. They've had it in their bundle since the second day. So when Your Honour tells them to decide the case on the evidence, the most natural reading available to twelve people who have just asked whether they may consider the no comment is that the answer is yes, it's part of the evidence, weigh it as you like. A short answer is only neutral if it can't be read as permission. This one can, and with respect it will be, because they asked the question precisely because they want to weigh it." She did not look at her notebook. She did not need to. "The written direction says they must not hold it against him. They've read it, and they've still sent the note. Re-reading it isn't going to tell them anything it didn't tell them on Friday. What they need is the plain answer to the question they asked, which is no. And they need to hear why, or the no will sound like a technicality and they'll go round it."
There was a pause. It was not a long one. She had stood in it before and knew exactly how long it was, and she was not uncomfortable in it, which was a thing she had learned in this room and nowhere else.
"Mr Tobin," the judge said. "Your view, now you've heard that."
Tobin had the grace to look at his own notebook for a moment, though there was nothing in it. "I take Ms Godwin's point about the evidence, Your Honour. The Crown never sought an inference and doesn't seek one now. I'd have no objection to the jury being told in terms."
"No," said the judge. "Nor would I, I think." He picked up his pen, wrote something, and looked at Alison for a moment over the top of the desk. Grey-blue eyes, very steady, in a face with long lines bracketing the mouth; a face that had spent thirty years being told things and deciding whether they were true. "Ms Godwin is right, and I'm obliged to her. The answer I proposed was short, but it wasn't neutral, and it's no good to me if it isn't both. I'll give them hers. And I'll add one thing of my own, because I think they'll need it: the reason the law gives, which isn't a technicality at all, and which they'll accept from me more readily than they'd accept a bare instruction." He put the pen down. "Sit down, Ms Godwin, you've won. Let's have them in."
She sat. She did not let her face do anything at all. Beside her, Corinne Whatley's trainee, a boy of twenty-three with a new suit and an iPad, let out a breath through his nose as though he had been holding it since the note arrived.
The jury filed back in at twenty-five past eleven, and the judge turned his chair a few degrees towards them, the way he did, so that he was talking to them and not at them.
"Members of the jury, thank you for your note. You've asked whether you're allowed to consider the fact that Mr Ellery answered no comment when he was interviewed by the police. The answer is no. You must not hold it against him in any way, and you must not treat it as any support for the prosecution case. I'll tell you why, because I think you're entitled to know." He did not hurry. "Everyone who is arrested and interviewed in this country has the right to say nothing. In some cases the law permits a jury to draw a conclusion from a person's silence, and when it does, the judge tells the jury so and explains the conditions very carefully. That isn't this case. The prosecution have not asked you to draw any conclusion from it, and I have directed you not to. If you were to hold it against him anyway, you would be punishing him for using a right the law gives him, and you would be doing it on the strength of something that proves nothing. So put it out of your minds. Decide the case on the evidence of what happened at that window, and nothing else."
He looked along both rows, unhurried, as though checking each of them had heard. Then he said, "Thank you. Please go back and continue your deliberations," and they went.
Alison wrote it down, word for word, as he said it. That was habit, and the habit was useful, because if she was writing she could not be watching the way he had looked along those two rows. She knew a good direction when she heard one. She had heard a great many from him. It was a defect in her, she thought, and a fairly specific one, that she should find it so much better when he had needed telling first.
They came back at three minutes to four. Not guilty, unanimous.
Ellery's mother cried in the gallery in a quiet, practical way, into a tissue she had evidently brought for the purpose either way. Ellery shook Alison's hand in the cells corridor with a roofer's grip and said, "Cheers, love. Cheers," three times, as if it were a sum he was getting right. She told him not to quote for anyone in Tupsley for a while. He laughed, which was the right answer.
When she came up the back stairs Corinne Whatley was waiting in the corridor outside the listing office, under the noticeboard with the week's lists pinned to it in cellophane sleeves. Corinne was fifty, Hereford born, a senior partner at Whatley Danvers who still went to the cells herself on Mondays, and she had a coat on and a bag over one shoulder and the look of a woman who had come to say one thing and go.
"Well done," she said. "Kevin said it was a nice bit of work on the note."
"It was a nice bit of work on the note. Kevin's learning."
"He is. He'll be insufferable by the summer." Corinne lowered the bag to the floor between her feet. "Norgate. Listing have fixed it. Monday the second of March, three days, Court 1."
Alison did not need to ask. She asked anyway, because she had been a barrister for twelve years and you always made them say it. "Before?"
"Prideaux." Corinne watched her. "You'll be all right with that."
It was not quite a question. Kyle Norgate was twenty-two and charged with unlawful wounding outside a pub in Leominster in August, and his case was an identification case, which meant it was a case about a judge's directions before it was a case about anything else. There was no judge on the circuit Alison would rather have had for it. That was simply true, and it was the reason she said, "Yes. Fine. He'll do it properly," and picked up her own bag, and put her hand on the stair rail.
"Five weeks," said Corinne. "I'll get you the unused by the end of the week. The CCTV's still a mess."
"It'll be a mess in five weeks."
"Probably," said Corinne, and went.
Alison stood a moment longer under the noticeboard. Through the glass panel of the listing office door she could see the clerk at her screen, the kettle, a calendar from a Leominster garage turned to January. Somewhere in the building a door closed with the particular heavy sound of the judges' corridor, which she had never been along and never would be, and which was no business of hers.
She drove home in the dark with the heater on her feet and the wig tin on the passenger seat.
The A49 north of Hereford was black and wet and nearly empty, cat's eyes running ahead of her into the bends, the long hedges coming up white in the headlights and dropping away behind. Leominster went past in a short smear of orange streetlights and a lit petrol forecourt. After that there was only the road and the shape of the hills to the west, darker than the sky, and the radio murmuring about the shipping forecast until she turned it off.
Monday the second of March. Court 1. Three days.
She had been in front of him perhaps a hundred times. She could have drawn the room from memory: the clock over the jury box that ran two minutes fast, the dent in the rail of the witness box, the way he took his glasses off to listen and put them back on to write. She could have told anyone who asked exactly what kind of judge he was — careful, fair, impatient with a lazy argument and never with a good one, and in six years she had not once known him dig in when he was wrong. That last was rarer than people outside the profession would believe. Men who had sat on a bench for a decade did not, as a rule, enjoy being told they had made a mistake by a woman twenty years younger in a borrowed robing-room mirror. He did not seem to enjoy it either. He simply took it, said so, and did better, and the better thing always came with its reason attached, as if he were obliged to her for the chance to show his working.
She held that thought where she usually held it, which was a little way off and in good light, so she could look at it without picking it up. She liked it. She liked very much — had liked for a long time, if she was being accurate, and she generally was — a man who had to justify himself to her and did it without sulking. That was all. It was not a plan and it was not a problem. It was a fact about her, the way the freckles across her nose were a fact about her in August, and there was no reason why a fact should have to be done anything about.
Ludlow came and went, the castle a dark lump above the town. The road narrowed. The first sign for Marlcaster showed up white and then green, and she took the turn without slowing, the way she had taken it most nights for five years.
The town was shut for the evening, as Marlcaster mostly was on a Monday in January. The market cross stood in the square with nobody under it. There were lights on at the Falcon and a man in a flat cap on the step of it, smoking, who turned his head to watch her car go by because he turned his head to watch every car go by. She went up past St Peter's, round the bend at the top of the hill, and into Castle Walk, where the houses were small and old and leaned slightly towards each other across the lane as though they had been talking for three hundred years and saw no reason to stop.
Her mother had been born in the end one. Alison parked outside it, turned off the engine, and sat for a moment in the ticking quiet of the car with the wig tin beside her and her hands still on the wheel.
Five weeks. It would be a good trial. He would sum up properly, and she would stand up when she had to, and that would be the whole of it.
She got out, locked the car, and went in to put the kettle on.
End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.