A sample from

The Second Reason

The auctioneer, Jonathan Tallis, was nearly twenty years too old for her and had not looked at her once all evening, and Abbie, who had looked at nothing else since the pudding, was beginning to take it personally.

At five to eleven Laurence Faircloth stood up at the top table and the Assembly Room went quiet for him without being asked, which Abbie had noticed was how the room treated him all evening. He thanked the Bell, and the kitchen, and the Young Farmers for the cup they had not broken this year, and the two Mr Reeses for being seated at opposite ends of the room without complaint, which got the biggest laugh of the night after the auction. He did it in about a minute and a half in a quiet, even voice that reached the back without trying, and then he sat down again, and a hundred and forty people began looking for their coats.

Abbie stayed where she was for a moment and let it happen around her. The tables were wrecked in the good way, cloths gone grey with crumbs and wine rings, the centrepieces of wheat and dahlias leaning, somebody's reading glasses abandoned in a sugar bowl. The long windows onto the yard had steamed from the inside. The sprung floor still gave a little under the people crossing it, so that her glass shivered on the cloth whenever a big man went past. At the side bar Tasha Mynott was pulling the last rounds she was going to pull for anyone sensible, and at the stage end Clare Tennant, in a navy jacket with her hair up and not a strand of it out of place after seven hours, was sending two of the Friday girls to the kitchen corridor with stacks of plates and one more to stand by the double doors and stop the Young Farmers taking the bunting home.

Abbie had come with the table from downstairs. Christine Brannock had bought it for the surgery in August and filled it with dentists and their wives and husbands, and had said, You're the only one of us half the farmers' children have actually met, which was true. Abbie had not expected to enjoy it. She had expected to sit between two men who wanted to know whether braces were really necessary or just fashionable, and that had happened, and she had told them what an untreated crossbite did to a jaw by forty in enough detail to stop them asking. After that the evening had improved.

It had also, from about the soup onwards, been the dress.

She had bought it in Bath in the summer and had nowhere to wear it until this, and she had nearly not worn it tonight, because the Agricultural Dinner was a room she was told ran to tweed. It was dark green silk, bias cut, plain at the front and up to the collarbones, and it fitted close over her breasts and in at the waist and then fell straight and heavy over her hips to the calf, so that it moved half a second after she did. The back was cut low, a long clean scoop to just above the base of her spine. In Bath, in a changing room, it had looked like a good dress. In the Assembly Room of the Bell, at a table of dentists, among a hundred and forty people from the farms and the land agents and the feed merchant's, it had turned out to be an event. She had felt the farming tables notice when she stood up for the toast, the way you feel a draught. She had decided at that point that she was thirty-three and had paid for it, and she had stopped thinking about it, mostly.

"You're the brace lady."

A woman in a navy two-piece and a brooch shaped like a ram's head had arrived at her elbow. Sixty, weathered, a farmer's wife from a long way back, with the look of someone who had been waiting for a gap.

"I am," Abbie said.

"Our Sam. Fourteen. He's on your list. He says you told him off about a toffee."

"I told him the toffee would cost him a bracket and an extra visit and that the extra visit would be in the middle of a school day. Which it was." She smiled the smile she used on fourteen-year-olds, and the woman, who had braced herself for a professional, relaxed. "He's doing well. His lower arch is coming round faster than I thought it would. Another eight months, perhaps ten, if he stays off the toffee."

"He won't."

"Then ten."

The woman laughed and touched her arm and went off towards the coats with the air of someone who would be reporting this, and Abbie found her clutch under her napkin and stood up.

The coat rail was on wheels along the corridor wall towards the hall, two hired chrome rails sagging under waxed jackets and good wool and a surprising quantity of fur that had been somebody's mother's. There was a crowd at it already, everybody reaching through everybody else. Abbie stood at the back of it in her heels and looked for the camel sleeve she knew was in the middle somewhere, and was working out how to get to it without being leant on when a hand went past her shoulder into the rail, unhooked it, and came back out with the coat held open by the collar.

"Camel," Jonathan said. "With the green lining. I saw you hang it."

She knew him the way you knew anybody in Marlcaster after three years: to nod to on the square on a Tuesday, to have pointed out to you at the Falcon, to have heard about from patients' parents in the chair with their mouths open, usually yours. Tallis's. The firm with the long board on the Corn Exchange and the cattle ring out on the ring road. She had not spoken to him until tonight, and tonight she had not spoken to him either. She had watched him.

He had sold the charity lots after the pudding. Eleven of them, for the air ambulance, from the stage, without the microphone, because the Bell's PA had howled once at the start and he had looked at it the way a man looks at a dog that has done something on the carpet and simply put it down. He had a voice that filled the Assembly Room from end to end with no apparent effort and he had used it to sell a case of wine, a day's rough shooting, a framed print of somebody's prize tup, and a long weekend at a holiday cottage on the coast that he had described, deadpan, as having a sea view on a clear day and a view of the bins on the others, and then got four hundred and twenty pounds for, against two men at the Young Farmers' table who had plainly been told by their wives to stop and had not. The room had laughed all the way through. He had not laughed once. He had knocked it down with a gavel he had brought in his pocket, and said, Sold, to the gentleman whose wife isn't speaking to him, and the room had come apart.

Close to, he was not as tall as he had looked on the stage. Five foot eleven, perhaps, but built heavy through the chest and shoulders, a thickset man whose dinner jacket had been cut by someone who understood that and had not tried to disguise it. Dark hair, very dark, near black, short at the sides and brushed back on top, thick as a younger man's. A close-trimmed dark beard. Brown eyes with lines at the corners of them that had come from weather rather than laughing, she thought, since he did not seem to do much of that himself. Fifty, or a little past it.

"Thank you," she said, and turned and let him put it on her.

He did it properly, holding it where her arms would go and lifting it onto her shoulders without making a thing of it. She felt the weight of the wool settle, and his hands leave it, and the cold corridor air on the bare skin of her back stop all at once.

"Do it up before you go out," he said. "The wind comes straight through that arch off the yard. You'll be warmer for the whole walk if you go out warm."

She looked at him. It was the kind of thing her father said. It was not said like her father, though. It was said the way he had said Four hundred, at the back, against you, sir: as a plain statement of where things stood, with the reason laid down next to it in case anybody wanted to check.

She did up the top two buttons.

"Where are you walking to?" he said.

"Mill Lane."

"Then you'll go out through the yard and under the arch. It's quicker than the front." He paused. "Give me your bag. You'll want a hand free for the setts in those."

"No," Abbie said. "I like knowing where it is."

"Fair enough," he said at once, and that was all. He did not look put out. He looked, if anything, as though he had made an offer, had it declined, and moved to the next lot.

She found she had liked that more than she would have liked being agreed with.

They went out through the double doors into the yard. The cold was clean after the room and smelled of the kitchen extractor and wet stone. The stable roofs were black against a sky still faintly orange from the town, and somebody had already started on the cellar flap against the left wall, a lad in a maroon jumper with his breath going up. The lamp on its bracket over the coach arch made a yellow pool on the cobbles and the dark under the arch beyond it looked deep and narrow.

"Walk on the inside going through," Jonathan said. "The wall side."

"Why?"

She asked it as she would have asked a nurse why a tray had been laid out differently. Not as a challenge. To know.

"The glass-hire van backs in under there at eleven to collect," he said. "They've a hundred and forty covers' worth of crates to load and they'll want to be home. He comes in fast because it's a tight turn off the square and he doesn't trust his reversing. If he comes in while we're under it, the inside is where you want to be."

She looked at her watch. It was three minutes past eleven.

"How do you know that?"

"I watched him try it at half past four while they were laying up, and swear, and try it again. I've backed a box trailer through that arch. It's a bad arch."

It was a good reason. It had the time in it, and the turn, and his having watched it, and she could check every part of it if she wanted to. She did not want to. She moved across to the wall side and went under the arch with the old brick close at her left shoulder and him on her right between her and the open cobbles, and it was only when they were out on the far side, on the edge of the square under the street lamps, that it occurred to her she had done exactly what she had been told, by a man she had never spoken to before tonight, without any part of her objecting.

Behind them, a moment later, there was the sound of a diesel engine and a reversing alarm, and white van lights swung across the arch and filled it.

"There he is," Jonathan said, not at all pleased with himself, and turned up the collar of his overcoat.

She thought about it across the square. She was not someone who did as she was told. She had a practice with her name on the brass plate at the bottom of the stairs and a chair booked six weeks ahead and a receptionist who rang her rather than make a decision about a cancellation, and she was the one at the top of the stairs who told everybody else where to stand. She had not been told what to do in any way that she had taken seriously since she left Birmingham. And she had just gone where she was put, because the reason was good, and the odd thing — the thing worth turning over — was that it had felt like a pleasure rather than a concession. As if somebody had cleared a small space for her and she had stepped into it.

She decided not to turn it over yet. They had reached the top of Corve Street.

"You're over the dental surgery," he said.

"I'm the first floor. Two rooms. One of them's mine and the other's empty." She nodded across the road as they passed it, at the dark first-floor windows and the lettering on the glass. "One chair. I'm booked to the twentieth of November."

"Six weeks."

"Six weeks and a day. I've had a mother ring me from Bellhurst in tears because her daughter's been told she has to wait till Christmas, and she had to wait till Christmas, because I can't put a second child in the one chair. That's what the back room's for. A second chair and somebody in it."

"Are you going to the bank?"

"I've been to the bank. Wendy Prewitt's had my numbers since June. She likes them. She hasn't said so, but she's measured the room twice."

"She would," he said. "She's measured my mezzanine four times in eleven years and never once lent me anything for it." He walked with his hands in his overcoat pockets, unhurried, matching her pace without seeming to notice he was doing it. "You'll get it. If the chair's booked six weeks out you'll get it."

"I know I'll get it."

"Yes," he said, and she heard that he had heard her, and that he had not been reassuring her in the first place but stating a valuation. "You would know."

End of sample. The story continues in the full edition.

Get the e-book